Where Should First-Time Visitors Stay in New York City?
Location is one of the most important decisions you’ll make when you’re planning your first trip to New York, and it’s usually more important than the hotel’s amenities or room rate. Staying in a hotel that’s inconveniently located will cause you to spend a surprising amount of your trip commuting back and forth, but an ideal hotel will allow you to walk to plenty of top sites or keep your subway rides below 30 minutes.
First-time visitors typically consider a handful of main areas: Midtown, Times Square, Central Park South, and Downtown Manhattan. Each has its own character and attributes, but Midtown tends to be the most practical choice for a first visit. Midtown sits right at the centre of the island of Manhattan, and it has excellent subway access in every direction, is highly walkable, and puts you close to the majority of the attractions most first-time visitors want to see.
Our Fitzpatrick Manhattan hotel puts you within about a 15-20 minute walk of the Museum of Modern Art, Broadway, Times Square, 5th Avenue shopping, Central Park, more. Staying in our Fitzpatrick Grand Central Hotel also puts you within just a 5-minute walk to Grand Central Terminal and a 12-minute walk to the famous Rockefeller Center.
Midtown East vs Times Square: Which Is Better for a First Visit?
This is one of the most common questions first-time visitors ask, and the honest answer is that it depends on what you want from your stay.
Times Square could be a good option if Broadway is your major priority, and it does deliver on the kind of first-time New York experience you’ve seen on the big screen with with plenty of bright lights, huge billboards, street performers, famous American brands and chain restaurants, and the high energy that never sleeps. It’s also extremely central. But the big trade-off is that Times Square can be noisy and feel overly crowded and hectic, particularly in the evenings, and staying right in the middle of it can make resting and sleeping more difficult.
Midtown East is still centrally located and surrounded by skyscrapers, but it’s much quieter and has more of a residential quality. You’re less than a 30-minute walk to Times Square, Broadway, Grand Central, Fifth Avenue, Bryant Park, and Rockefeller Center, and you have easy access to Central Park from its southern entrance. Many visitors find Midtown to be less overwhelming as a place to actually stay, with a few more local restaurants and businesses as an added bonus.
Remember that you don’t need to stay in Times Square to experience it, and Times Square is a short walk or subway ride from Midtown East. For travellers who want a central location but a calmer environment to return to at the end of a long sightseeing day, Midtown East is a great option. Neither area is objectively better, so it just comes down to your unique priorities and travel style.